David Bisard case affecting 2013 legislative session

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

One of the laws introduced at the start of 2013’s legislative session was Senate Bill 168.  If it is passed, it could have a huge impact on drunk driving cases in our state.  The bill was inspired by the case against Officer David Bisard.

It is a case that continues to twist and turn.  On Aug. 6, 2010, Bisard crashed into three motorcyclists on his way to serve a warrant.  Two were seriously injured and another was killed.

Was Officer Bisard drunk?  Bisard’s blood was tested, and was found to be more than three times the legal limit, with a blood alcohol content of .19.  The officer’s case was far from open and shut though, because the blood was taken at a medical clinic by a medical assistant. That was a violation of current Indiana law.  State Sen. Randy Head wants that law changed.

“There is a technicality in the law that can benefit drunk drivers and we need to make the court about finding the truth and not about upholding technicalities that the legislature put in,” said Head.

Senator Head wrote Senate Bill 168.  The law’s only change is that anyone, properly trained, can take a sample and have it used in court.

“What I am trying to do is take a situation that maybe was not as well thought out as it should have been and allow anyone who is trained to do the work that they are trained to do,” said Senator Head.

The officer is charged with DUI and reckless homicide, after the Indiana Supreme Court denied the request to have his blood thrown out as evidence.

“I felt from day one that we had very compelling arguments as to why the blood draw was appropriate, in spite of the ambiguity among the statutes, and at this point, the Court of Appeals has agreed,” said Marion County Prosecutor Terry Curry.

Senator Head wants future cases to be more clear-cut. But the family of Eric Wells, the motorcyclist who was killed in the August accident, just wants the current case to move forward.

“It is there with you every day, the time does not help,” said Aaron Wells, Eric’s father.  “You just want a time where you can heal.”

Bisard’s trial will not play out in Marion County, the case is moving to either the northern or southern part of the state.  That decision will be made on Feb. 14.  As for Senate Bill 168, it must be passed in either January or February of this year’s legislative session.

You can read Senate Bill 168 in its entirety online. To see Senate Bill 168 in its entirety, click on the link: http://www.in.gov/legislative/bills/2013/IN/IN0168.1.html


  • Dee

    He should have already been tried and sentenced to prison. But alas just because he has the title of cop they're dragging their feet…but if it was the average Joe they'd already be sent up the river.

  • BEW

    Why isnt his ass in jail, awaiting trial !? He took someones life. Why is he allowed to get all his ducks in a row before his trial and possible sentance to major jail time. The man that he killed had no time to prepare anything, nor did his family…HE SHOULD BE IN JAIL AWAITING TRIAL….QUIT DRAGGING IT OUT….PUT HIM AWAY !!!

    • JJJ

      Now they are making new laws so they can say "this will never happen again" after Bisard gets probation. They will probably even call it the "Bisard Act" or some crap like that.

      Smoke and mirrors is all this is.

  • Papa Smurf

    How many normal (non-cops) individuals have already been sentenced, tried, and sent up the river for drunk driving on less evidence? So, again, I will ask the question that has been asked over and over and over again; Why isn't Bissard in jail now?

  • Steve

    Indiana should take all the money they spend on commercials about if you drive drunk in Indiana you will go to jail. Wake up and smell the booze boys. This is not so. Get a good attorney and get a plea bargain so you can do it again and again. You make the choice to drink and drive so you should go to jail. This is not a disease cause it is you choice. There to again drinking is socially acceptable. Well maybe something will be done when a senator or state representative's son, wife, daughter gets killed or something and then and only then will something be done.

  • Perry

    Why hasn't anything done to the officers who knowingly took Bisard to an unapproved collection facility? Why hasn't anything been done to the officers who removed the samples from refrigeration in the evidence room? I know the FBI said there was no evidence of it being done on purpose. Who believes that???? If they don't get punished it will continue to happen. How about the names of those officers? Bisard is not the only one guilty of criminal neglect in this case!

Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.