Court overturns former principal’s conviction in student rape case

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

A former principal convicted of failing to report a rape that happened at his school was cleared of any wrongdoing Wednesday.

From conviction, to vindication, former Muncie Central High School Principal Chris Smith’s sentence has been overturned by the Indiana Court of Appeals.

“Very pleased, very pleased,” said Chris Smith’s attorney, Scott Shockley. “We feel like it was a very detailed, thorough opinion and a very fair result.”

Smith took major heat in 2010, after a 16-year-old girl was raped inside a bathroom at the school.  Smith was charged with failure to immediately report child abuse or neglect.  He allegedly waited 4.5 hours to call police.  Shockley said too much of the blame was put on Smith.

“Events as they unfolded at Muncie Central were viewed by a number of administrators and that includes some people at the administration building and not at the school,” said Shockley. “The same way that Mr. Smith viewed them.  Nobody viewed the events, that afternoon, as potentially child abuse.”

Smith was convicted, his sentence consisted of suspended jail time, probation, and community service.  After his conviction was overturned Smith’s life did not go back to normal. He is no longer the principal of Muncie Central High School though he has another job within the corporation.

“It was very stressful for, not just Chris, but also his family,” said Shockley.  “There was a lot of publicity surrounding this whole matter, it was a very unfortunate matter for the school and Chris suffered a great deal through all of that.”

Student Steven Moore was charged with raping the student. Moore was 16, but was tried as an adult. He pleaded guilty to the rape and was sentenced in 2011.

Two members of the Court of Appeals sided with Smith, one did not.  The member who dissented said Smith’s actions ignored, “the common-sense conclusion that when a child is the victim of abuse – regardless of the age of the perpetrator – the act is abuse of a child.”

Shockley knows Smith is still guilty in the public’s eyes and his life will never be the same.

“It is hard to get your story out when public reaction was the way it seemed to be during this case,” said Shockley.

Shockley said the incident has forced the Muncie Central School Corporation and other schools across the state to come up with a better plan to prevent something like this from happening again.

The process Smith is not over yet.  The Attorney General’s Office can file a motion to have Smith’s case heard by the Indiana Supreme Court. The Office has 30 days to file that motion.

Related Stories:


  • Hoosierdad

    aww, was it stressful for him? that poor baby. hes lucky the girl who was raped didnt have a dad. if that was my daughter, hed be lucky if he was out of beating induced coma i put him in. its pretty bad when the unions get a win on this one. i guess we should get used to our kids being treated like animals because everyone is more worried about what someone else might think. we need to dissolve all public unions, starting with the teachers union

  • Denise

    We knew he would be cleared did'nt we .The person I feel sorry for is the victim not this adult that was suppose to be in charge and turned his head .How stressful for the victims family, he brought the stress on himself and his family he is almost as guilty as the criminal that did the crime,He should never have a position with children again,Am wondering if he had a daughter and this happened to her how long he would have waited

  • cjmo

    I'm sorry, but I don't get why nobody thought the rape of a child doesn't constitute child abuse! I'm glad that he lost his position, and hope the current administration doesn't repeat his actions by delaying reporting incidents of child abuse; their job is to protect children- they failed, it's that simple.

Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.